Presolar grains: Interstellar Messengers to Study Hands-On Astrophysics



Reto Trappitsch
March 20, 2024



Stellar messengers in our solar system

Presolar grains | Reto Trappitsch | Mar 20, 2024

A zoo of presolar grains

  • Nanodiamonds: ~106 atoms
  • Silicon carbide: The hardy ones
  • Graphites: Large but fragile
  • Silicates: Small and fragile
  • ...

Silicon Carbide (SiC) are the best studied phase due to their size and hardiness

Presolar grains | Reto Trappitsch | Mar 20, 2024

Silicon Carbide grains: Are they presolar?

  • δ-units: Deviation from solar in ‰
  • Presolar grains have extreme isotope compositions
  • Classified by analyzing Si, C, & N isotopes
  • Fingerprint of the parent star's composition
  • Hands-on astrophysical samples
    • Galactic chemical evolution
    • Stellar nucleosynthesis

Presolar grains | Reto Trappitsch | Mar 20, 2024

Silicon Carbide grains: Are they presolar?

  • δ-units: Deviation from solar in ‰
  • Presolar grains have extreme isotope compositions
  • Classified by analyzing Si, C, & N isotopes
  • Fingerprint of the parent star's composition
  • Hands-on astrophysical samples
    • Galactic chemical evolution
    • Stellar nucleosynthesis

Presolar grains | Reto Trappitsch | Mar 20, 2024

Cosmic-ray induced spallation in the interstellar medium

Production rates can be modeled with cosmic-ray spectrum in interstellar medium

Trappitsch and Leya (2016)
Presolar grains | Reto Trappitsch | Mar 20, 2024

How old are presolar grains? At least 4.5 billion years!

  • Cosmic-rays induce production of nuclides
  • Ideal proxy for exposure age:
    21Ne concentration
    • Does not condense into grain
    • Produced from Si
  • Most grains formed <1 Ga prior to solar system
  • Some grains are several billion years old!

Presolar grains | Reto Trappitsch | Mar 20, 2024

Sample preparation

Chemical separation

  • Dissolve meteorite with acids
  • Heavy liquid separation

Finding the needle in the haystack by burning down the hay

Presolar grains | Reto Trappitsch | Mar 20, 2024

Sample deposition on ultra-clean gold foil

Presolar grains | Reto Trappitsch | Mar 20, 2024

Sample imaging

  • Mapping sample mount with secondary electron microscope
  • Identify presolar grains by energy dispersive X-Ray spectroscopy

Maps aid in navigating the sample mount

Presolar grains | Reto Trappitsch | Mar 20, 2024

Presolar grains | Reto Trappitsch | Mar 20, 2024

Sample classification

  • Analyze C, N, and Si isotopes
  • Nanoscale secondary ion imaging
  • Ideal instrument to measure major element isotopes

Determine the type of parent star for each grain

Presolar grains | Reto Trappitsch | Mar 20, 2024

Trace element isotopes

  • Need for a high-sensitivity technique
  • Resonance Ionization Mass Spectrometry (RIMS)
    • Useful yield up to 40%
    • No isobaric interferences
  • Currently only two instruments world-wide
  • RIMS allows measuring most of the periodic table
Presolar grains | Reto Trappitsch | Mar 20, 2024
Presolar grains | Reto Trappitsch | Mar 20, 2024
Presolar grains | Reto Trappitsch | Mar 20, 2024
Presolar grains | Reto Trappitsch | Mar 20, 2024
Presolar grains | Reto Trappitsch | Mar 20, 2024
Presolar grains | Reto Trappitsch | Mar 20, 2024
Presolar grains | Reto Trappitsch | Mar 20, 2024
Presolar grains | Reto Trappitsch | Mar 20, 2024


top-left

RIMS: Separate isobars during analysis

center

Presolar grains | Reto Trappitsch | Mar 20, 2024

Asymptotic giant branch (AGB) stars

  • Expand rapidly and cool
  • Cycles between H and He burning
  • Copious dust producers
  • Host of the s-process
  • Two important neutron sources
    • 13C(α,n)16O
    • 22Ne(α,n)25Mg
Presolar grains | Reto Trappitsch | Mar 20, 2024

The two neutron sources at work

13C(α,n)16O

  • Main s-process neutron source
  • Neutron density: < 107 cm-3
  • Thousands of years

22Ne(α,n)25Mg

  • Bottom of He intershell
  • Max. neutron density ~109 cm-3
  • A few years
Presolar grains | Reto Trappitsch | Mar 20, 2024

We can see these signatures in presolar grains!

center

Presolar grains | Reto Trappitsch | Mar 20, 2024

Deciphering the stellar conditions

  • SiC condense only if C/O > 1
  • Heavier stars get hotter
    • Stronger 22Ne(α,n)25Mg
    • Produce more 96Zr
  • Nuclear physics complicates picture further
  • Presolar grains allow deciphering stellar conditions
see, e.g., Liu et al. (20xx), Stephan et al. (2019)

center

AGB models: Lugaro et al. (2018)
Presolar grains | Reto Trappitsch | Mar 20, 2024

Deciphering the stellar conditions

  • SiC condense only if C/O > 1
  • Heavier stars get hotter
    • Stronger 22Ne(α,n)25Mg
    • Produce more 96Zr
  • Nuclear physics complicates picture further
  • Presolar grains allow deciphering stellar conditions
see, e.g., Liu et al. (20xx), Stephan et al. (2019)

center

AGB models: Lugaro et al. (2018)
Presolar grains | Reto Trappitsch | Mar 20, 2024

Deciphering the stellar conditions

  • SiC condense only if C/O > 1
  • Heavier stars get hotter
    • Stronger 22Ne(α,n)25Mg
    • Produce more 96Zr
  • Nuclear physics complicates picture further
  • Presolar grains allow deciphering stellar conditions
see, e.g., Liu et al. (20xx), Stephan et al. (2019)

center

AGB models: Lugaro et al. (2018)
Presolar grains | Reto Trappitsch | Mar 20, 2024

Deciphering the stellar conditions

  • SiC condense only if C/O > 1
  • Heavier stars get hotter
    • Stronger 22Ne(α,n)25Mg
    • Produce more 96Zr
  • Nuclear physics complicates picture further
  • Presolar grains allow deciphering stellar conditions
see, e.g., Liu et al. (20xx), Stephan et al. (2019)

center

AGB models: Lugaro et al. (2018)
Presolar grains | Reto Trappitsch | Mar 20, 2024

Deciphering the stellar conditions

  • SiC condense only if C/O > 1
  • Heavier stars get hotter
    • Stronger 22Ne(α,n)25Mg
    • Produce more 96Zr
  • Nuclear physics complicates picture further
  • Presolar grains allow deciphering stellar conditions
see, e.g., Liu et al. (20xx), Stephan et al. (2019)

center

AGB models: Lugaro et al. (2018)
Presolar grains | Reto Trappitsch | Mar 20, 2024

Deciphering the stellar conditions

  • SiC condense only if C/O > 1
  • Heavier stars get hotter
    • Stronger 22Ne(α,n)25Mg
    • Produce more 96Zr
  • Nuclear physics complicates picture further
  • Presolar grains allow deciphering stellar conditions
see, e.g., Liu et al. (20xx), Stephan et al. (2019)

center

AGB models: Lugaro et al. (2018)
Presolar grains | Reto Trappitsch | Mar 20, 2024














Cassipeia A: Si, S, Ca, Fe, X-Ray (Credit: NASA/CXC/SAO)
Presolar grains | Reto Trappitsch | Mar 20, 2024

Presolar supernova grains directly probe the ejecta

  • Dust condensation timeframe:
    ~20 years (Ott et al., 2009)

  • State-of-the art: 1D mixing models

  • Future: 3D condensation models

    • Directly compare to presolar grains
    • Understand the dust formation process
  • We need more measurements and detailed models!

Presolar grains | Reto Trappitsch | Mar 20, 2024
Fryer et al. (2023)
















The galactic chemical evolution (GCE) puzzle

  • Presolar grains are older than the solar system
  • However, many of them are enriched in 29Si and 30Si compared to the sun
  • Heterogeneous GCE
  • Models predict a slope ~1 line for correlation
  • Actual measurements show slope 1.34 (Stephan et al., 2024)
Presolar grains | Reto Trappitsch | Mar 20, 2024

The influence of nuclear reaction rates on the slope

center

Fok et al. (in prep.)
Presolar grains | Reto Trappitsch | Mar 20, 2024

Stellar nucleosynthesis effects

Nuclear reaction rate uncertainties have a large influence, especially on 29Si
Fok et al. (in prep.)
Presolar grains | Reto Trappitsch | Mar 20, 2024

C-O shell mergers complicate the picture further

center

  • Ritter et al. (2017) proposed shell mergers solve abundance of odd-Z elements
  • Isotopes do not agree and are a much finer probe!
Presolar grains | Reto Trappitsch | Mar 20, 2024

Nuclear reaction rate uncertainties are important!

  • Measured slope (dashed line) lays well within 95% confidence interval (dotted line) of model predictions
Presolar grains | Reto Trappitsch | Mar 20, 2024

Presolar grain analysis: Hands-on astrophysics...

  • Presolar grains are isotopic messenger
  • Fine probes for many processes
    • GCE
    • Rare nucleosynthesis processes
    • Ejecta mixing & condensation
  • Recent advances in measurement techniques

Stay tuned!

SiC grain imaged in the secondary electron microscope
Presolar grains | Reto Trappitsch | Mar 20, 2024

Presolar grain analysis: Hands-on astrophysics...

  • Presolar grains are isotopic messenger
  • Fine probes for many processes
    • GCE
    • Rare nucleosynthesis processes
    • Ejecta mixing & condensation
  • Recent advances in measurement techniques

Stay tuned!

Presolar grains | Reto Trappitsch | Mar 20, 2024

... or astronomy with a microscope











xkcd.com
Presolar grains | Reto Trappitsch | Mar 20, 2024

Acknowledgement

Hung Kwan Fok
Stéphane Escrig, Cristina Martin Olmos, Anders Meibom, Florent Plane
Brett Isselhardt, Wei Jia Ong, Mike Savina, Ziva Shulaker
Chris Fryer, Chris Mauney
Andy Davis, Mike Pellin, Philipp Heck, Thomas Stephan
Benoit Côté, Marco Pignatari, Maria Lugaro
Presolar grains | Reto Trappitsch | Mar 20, 2024